B3410 - Testing the role of relative age within school year on mental health in children with neurodevelopmental vulnerability - 24/11/2019

B number: 
B3410
Principal applicant name: 
Stephan Collishaw | Cardiff University (UK)
Co-applicants: 
Mr Tom Broughton, Professor Kate Tilling, Dr Kate Langley, Dr Richard Anney
Title of project: 
Testing the role of relative age within school year on mental health in children with neurodevelopmental vulnerability
Proposal summary: 

In England and Wales, the academic year begins in the September, and children start school in September before they are five years old. If children are born in September, then they are nearly five when they start school, but if they are born in August in the following chronological year then they have only just turned four years old when the school year starts. Studies have shown that the youngest children within a school year are at an increased risk for mental health problems, social impairment, neurodevelopmental disorder and intellectual disability diagnoses, and lower educational attainment (Bedard & Dhuey, 2006; Zoëga et al., 2012; Pottegård et al, 2014; Root et al., 2019). Cross-national comparisons of large representative population surveys that compare countries with different school entry dates have suggested that associations may reflect causal influences of age within school year on these outcomes, rather than season-of-birth (Goodman et al., 2003). This project will focus on children with early neurodevelopmental vulnerability, which will be defined using neurodevelopmental symptoms and diagnoses, genetic risk, or prematurity of birth. These children are all already at a higher risk of mental health problems including depression (Rice et al., 2018). We hypothesise that relative age effects may affect these groups of children more than others over development from childhood to adulthood. We also hypothesise that differences in mental health by month of birth will emerge only after school entry but show some persistence across the school years into early adulthood.

Impact of research: 
This project will likely be impactful as it aims to be assess whether age at school entry is causally associated with later mental health difficulties in specific at-risk groups. The project will help identify those children who are at highest risk of later mental health problems, and who are therefore a priority for early support and preventative intervention. Furthermore, identifying a group(s) of children who would benefit from delaying school entry has potentially significant individual, family and societal benefits. Currently, guidance in England and Wales indicates that it is possible to delay school entry if there is a ‘compelling reason’. However, decisions on deferred school entry are often left to individual school admission boards, and policy varies between the devolved nations. The project will provide comprehensive evidence on whether children at risk should be rigidly assigned to school entry based on date of birth or given greater flexibility regarding school entry, taking into account developmental maturity. Therefore, the findings of this project would be of significant interest to parents, carers, and teachers of premature children and children with neurodevelopmental disorders, as well as charities that advocate for these groups. The findings will also be of interest to the Welsh Government, UK Government, and local education authorities.
Date proposal received: 
Friday, 15 November, 2019
Date proposal approved: 
Sunday, 17 November, 2019
Keywords: 
Mental health - Psychology, Psychiatry, Cognition, Mental health, Statistical methods, Cohort studies - attrition, bias, participant engagement, ethics, Childhood - childcare, childhood adversity, Environment - enviromental exposure, pollution, Genetic epidemiology, Statistical methods